Topic
Plain Error
57 published works
Supreme Court Update
Hardt v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance Co. (09-448), United States v. Marcus (08-1341) and United States v. O’Brien (08-1569)
By Kim Rinehart
As promised, this Update covers the Court's three other opinions from Monday: Hardt v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance Co. (09-448), which addresses attorney's fees under a specific ERISA provision, but…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Sixth Circuit panel splits over procedural reasonableness and plain error review
Main March 16, 2010Sixth Circuit panel splits over procedural reasonableness and plain error review The Sixth Circuit has a notable and divided discussion of procedural reasonableness and plain error review…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Fourth Circuit adopts plain-error review for unpreserved error of inadequate explanation
Main January 28, 2010Fourth Circuit adopts plain-error review for unpreserved error of inadequate explanation Joining most other circuit that have considered the question, the Fourth Circuit today in US v.…
EvidenceProf Blog
Plain Truth: Court Of Appeals Of Minnesota Fails To Conduct Plain Error Review Of Business Records Ruling
By Colin Miller
In relevant part, Federal Rule of Evidence 803(6) provides a exception to the rule against hearsay for A memorandum, report, record, or data compilation, in any form, of acts, events, conditions, opinions,…
Sentencing Law and Policy
First Circuit finds plain error when sentence based on inaccurate facts
Main April 10, 2009First Circuit finds plain error when sentence based on inaccurate factsThe First Circuit handed down a notable little sentencing opinion dealing with plain error yesterday in US…
EvidenceProf Blog
I’m A Soldier: Supreme Court of Missouri Finds Closing Statement Comparing Jurors To Soldiers Is Not Plain Error
By Colin Miller
According to the Supreme Court of Missouri's recent opinion in State v. McLaughlin, 2008 WL 3906355 (Mo. 2008), a prosecutor's closing statement comparing jurors to soldiers is not plain error. …
Sentencing Law and Policy
Blakelyplain error in Oregon
Main March 31, 2006Blakely plain error in OregonThe story of Booker plain error in the federal system has been amazing to watch, though slowly but surely the issue has been…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Eighth Circuit keeping theBookerpipeline interesting
Main August 2, 2005Eighth Circuit keeping the Booker pipeline interestingThough I have long given up on keeping up with all the sentencing action in Eighth Circuit, today on the circuit's…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Potent comments on preservingBookererror
Main July 25, 2005Potent comments on preserving Booker errorThe different ways that different circuits are treating Booker plain error remains highly consequential and highly visible as cases continue to move…
Sentencing Law and Policy
Barnett receives lower sentence after remand
Main July 10, 2005Barnett receives lower sentence after remandAfter a bit of a rocky start handling Booker plain error, the Sixth Circuit in US v. Barnett, No. 04-5252 (6th Cir.…