Topic
Proportionality
76 published works
All About eDiscovery
Proportionality Is the Critical Inquiry in Federal Court Discovery
By Katie Cole
The amendment to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(1) (which defines the scope of permissible discovery) did away with the timeworn “reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible…
Drug & Device Law
Another Champion for Proportionality in Discovery
For the second time within a month, an MDL court has rejected wide-ranging and potentially abusive discovery on the basis that the requests were out of proportion to the needs…
Drug & Device Law
Rules Amendments Mean That Proportionality Limits Even MDL Discovery
By Bexis
We’ve blogged several times over the past couple years about the 2015 amendments to the federal rules as they pertain to discovery, including electronic discovery. Earlier this year, after the…
Class Action Lawsuit Defense
Post-Tyson Foods, Defendants Should Take the Offensive in Discovery Sampling
Following the Supreme Court’s ruling in Tyson Foods and in light of the greater emphasis on proportionality in the amended Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, defendants can expect to see…
Drug & Device Law
Disproportionate Discovery, Even in an MDL
By Bexis
Here’s a significant post-rules-amendments discovery decision out of the Xarelto MDL. In In re Xarelto (Rivaroxaban) Products Liability Litigation, 2016 WL 311762 (E.D. La. Jan. 26, 2016), the court (Fallon,…
Internet, IT & e-Discovery
Supreme Court thinks proportionality will help eDiscovery, but not everyone agrees
By Peter Vogel
In support of the 2015 Amendments to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Chief Justice John Roberts said that “Rule 26(b)(1) crystalizes the concept of reasonable limits on discovery through…
Discovery Advocate
Day 1: Your First Five Questions (times four): A Practical Guide to the Amended Federal Rules of Civil Procedure – Proportionality
By Karin Scholz Jenson, Gary Levin, Robert J. Tucker, James A. Sherer, Jonathan A. Forman
The current amended Federal Rules of Civil Procedure—and, in particular, those that address the practice of civil discovery—are the product of five years of development, debate, and, of course, dialogue.…
Banking, Finance and Securities
The principle of proportionality: application in the Single Supervisory Mechanism
The European Central Bank (ECB) has published a letter that it has sent to Sven Giegold MEP. The letter provides an overview of how the principle of proportionality is applied…
Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog
Duke Center Drafts Its Own “Guidelines” for Proportionality Amendments
The Center for Judicial Studies of Duke Law School has issued a draft of “Guidelines and Suggested Practices for Implementing the 2015 Discovery Amendments to Achieve Proportionality.” The Center has…
Drug & Device Law
Proportionality – If You Can Keep It
By Bexis
Walking out of the Constitutional Convention on its final day, back in 1789, Benjamin Franklin was (supposedly) asked what kind of government he had helped create for the new entity to be known…