Topic
Proportionality
76 published works
Civil Procedure & Federal Courts Blog
FRCP Amendments Will Narrow (Once Again) the Scope of Discovery
The changes proposed to the scope of discovery center around the third "theme" of the 2010 Duke Conference: proportionality. The proposed contraction of the scope of discovery under Rule 26(b)…
Sentencing Law and Policy
“Into the Breach: The Case for Robust Noncapital Proportionality Review Under State Constitutions”
Main July 2, 2014"Into the Breach: The Case for Robust Noncapital Proportionality Review Under State Constitutions"The title of this post is the title of this notable piece authored by Samuel…
Drug & Device Law
Breaking News: Proposal to Amend Federal Rules Finalized
By Bexis
The so-called “Duke Subcommittee” today finalized and voted on its version of proposed amendments to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. These amendments include those we’ve blogged about before, making alterations to the…
ImmigrationProf Blog
Court Weighs Whether Deportation Fits Crime
The National Law Journal reports on oral arguments in the U.S. Court of Appeals on Wednesday in a case about whether immigration judges must consider whether deportation amounts to disproportional…
Technology Law Source
Key e-discovery cases in October
Here are my thoughts on key e-discovery cases decided in October, including a decision in which the court was highly critical of a party’s “single-minded focus on discovery of ESI,”…
E-Discovery
Proportionality: Why Considering Overall Value of Case is Important in Discovery—Judge Michael Baylson
No matter the venture, it's always advantageous to keep one's eyes on the big picture—to look past the nitty gritty details of the current challenge and on to what's most…
ImmigrationProf Blog
Exploring “Discretion” and “Proportionality” in Immigration
The concepts of discretion and proportionality are deeply ingrained in the American justice system. When creating and enforcing the law, government officials must constantly evaluate when and where to apply…
ImmigrationProf Blog
Immigration Article of the Day: Immigration Law and the Proportionality Requirement by Michael Wishnie
"Immigration Law and the Proportionality Requirement" University of California Irvine Law Review (immigrtaion symposium), Forthcoming MICHAEL J. WISHNIE, Yale Law School.ABSTRACT: Proportionality is the notion that the severity of a…
Sentencing Law and Policy
“Practicing Proportionality”
Main September 4, 2011"Practicing Proportionality"The title of this post is the title of this notable new paper by Professor William W. Berry III. Here is the abstract: At the heart…
Sentencing Law and Policy
“Rethinking Proportionality Under the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause”
Main August 24, 2010"Rethinking Proportionality Under the Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause" The title of this post is the title of this terrific-looking new article by John Stinneford that is…