Topic
Vertical Restraints
94 published works
Retail & Consumer Products Law Observer
Robust State Enforcement of Minimum Resale Price Maintenance May Require New Approaches to Pricing
'resale price maintenance', antitrust
Antitrust Law Blog
Lights Out for Resale Price and Dual Distribution Class Action
On December 2, 2010, the Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit affirmed a ruling of dismissal entered by the United States District for the Northern District of Georgia. Jacobs…
Blog of Reason
So You Still Think You’re Safe Under the Antitrust Laws? Another Word of Advice To Those Who Would Ignore The States
By Robert Langer, Erica Amarante
Eight years ago, in the fall of 2002, we authored an article in the pages of the Antitrust Report that warned of the dangers of assuming that state antitrust law would always…
China Law Blog
China Distribution and Resale Price Maintenance
By Dan Harris
Excellent China Law Insight post on resale price maintenance in China, entitled, Rules Governing Resale Price Maintenance in China. Now before you just run away, believing there is no way…
China Law Insight
中国法律对限制转售价格行为的规范
宁宣凤、Angie Ng、郑孜青,金杜反垄断与反不正当竞争组 由于中国是世界制造中心,在这里企业之间的纵向服务合同或协议(如生产商与经销商之间)非常普遍,因此,中国反垄断法中有关规范纵向限制(如限制转售价格行为)的法律规定显得尤为重要。 本文将简要分析中国反垄断法中有关规范限制转售价格行为的法律规定,并将与欧盟竞争法中类似规定进行比较。 中国 《反垄断法》第14条禁止经营者与交易相对人达成关于固定向第三人转售商品价格(尤其是限定转售商品的最低价格)的协议。也就是说,法律不允许甲制造商限制乙经销商向丙分销商转售商品的价格。 然而,此项严格限制也有例外情形。 如果经营者能够证明其限制行为满足以下情形之一的,则不适用《反垄断法》第14条的规定: · 限制价格的目的是为了改进技术、研究开发新产品; · 为提高产品质量、降低成本、提高效率,统一产品规格、标准或者实行专业化分工的; · 为提高中小经营者经营效率,增强其竞争力的; · 为实现节约能源、保护环境、救灾救助等社会公共利益的; · 因经济不景气,为缓解销售量严重下降或者生产明显过剩的; · 为保障对外贸易和对外经济合作中的正当利益的; 纵观全球,中国对限制转售价格行为的严格禁止并非个例,像欧盟、澳大利亚这些反垄断法发展比较成熟的国家和地区也在此方面做出了类似的规定。 欧盟 欧盟竞争法并无明确条文规定限制纵向的上下游企业之间的限制转售价格的行为,但是,该法第101条第1款第a项规定:禁止经营者之间的价格限制行为。根据实践,该条文的规定可同时适用在存在横向竞争关系的和存在纵向的(如原材料供应)供应关系的经营者之间。如此看来,有关限制转售价格的行为均受欧盟竞争法101条第1款第a的约束。 另外,限制转售价格行为也是“欧盟纵向限制集体豁免条例”的重点规范对象,该规定的最新版本及配套指南于2010年6月1日生效,有效期至2022年5月31日。因此,构成限制转售价格的行为很可能将违反欧盟竞争法的101条。 与中国反垄断法相同的是,欧盟竞争法也对禁止限制转售价格行为做了豁免性规定,该法第101条第3款列出了一个宽泛的关于“效益”的豁免规定, 即,如果限制转售价格的协议目的是为了改进产品或产品销售,或者是为了促进技术或经济进步,相关协议则不适用第101条的规定。换句话说,如果某企业能够证明其关于限制转售价格的行为是为了提高效益,其行为不受该条款的限制。 “欧盟纵向限制集体豁免条例”配套指引重点列出了可豁免竞争法101条第1款规定的行为类型,主要包括以下几种情形: · 制造商推出新产品时可能需要限制转售价格;(如果销售市场竞争激烈,考虑到生产企业的开发积极性及开发成本需求,适当的允许生产企业和分销企业对转售价格进行限制将有利于新产品的开发和销售,并最终使广大消费者受益); · …
China Law Insight
Rules Governing Resale Price Maintenance in China
By Susan Ning, Angie Ng and Zheng Ziqing, King & Wood's Competition Practice Antitrust or competition law rules governing vertical restraints (such as resale price maintenance) are significant in China…
Antitrust Law Blog
Fifth Circuit Dismisses Leegin Resale Price Maintenance Case Anew, Following Supreme Court Remand
In 2007, the United States Supreme Court, updating the application of the cumulative advances in antitrust economics as applied to vertical restraint cases, overruled the venerable Dr. Miles Med. Co.…
Antitrust Law Blog
Fifth Circuit Dismisses <i>Leegin</i> Resale Price Maintenance Case Anew, Following Supreme Court Remand
In 2007, the United States Supreme Court, updating the application of the cumulative advances in antitrust economics as applied to vertical restraint cases, overruled the venerable Dr. Miles Med. Co.…
Antitrust, Competition and Trade
Banning “Pay-For Delay” Settlements and Resale Price Maintenance are Senate Antitrust Subcommittee’s Top Legislative Priorities
In a recent interview, Senator Herb Kohl (D-Wis.), Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee's subcommittee on antitrust, competition policy and consumer rights, discussed the subcommittee's legislative priorities for 2010. At the…
Antitrust Law Blog
A Window into Washington: Proposed Legislation to Prohibit Resale Price Maintenance Agreements
Congress has taken preliminary steps to adopt legislation that would restore the rule that minimum resale price agreements between manufacturers and retailers, distributors or wholesalers, violate the Sherman Act without…