Skip to main content

Labor Law Prof Blog

Is Automatic Enrollment Making a 401(k) Difference?

By Workplace Prof

Maybe not.  PlanSponsor.com has this interesting re-think article on the benefits of employers offering automatic enrollment options for their salary deferral/401(k) plans.  Here are some highlights:

The 10th annual version of PLANSPONSOR‘s assessment of the activities of nearly 5,000 plan sponsors (see 2006 PLANSPONSOR DC Survey: Brave New World) found that the median participation rate for plans that had implemented automatic enrollment was 80%. Now, that’s certainly nothing to sneeze at, but it’s not very much ahead of the 75% median rate for the plans in the same survey that had not taken the step toward automatic enrollment—and it’s well short of the outcome that one normally sees touted alongside that option (generally in the 90-95% participation range) . . . .

[E]ven with the passage of the PPA . . . automatic enrollment safe harbor does not require a retroactive application.

In fact, IMHO, it seems quite likely that this decision to implement these programs on a “prospective only” basis likely accounts for the negligible uptick in participation rates in automatic plans reporting in PLANSPONSOR’s DC Survey.

It still may be early to make any good predictions about the impact that automatic enrollment will have on an employee retirement investment behavior, but, at the very least, there is much food for thought here.

PS

Originally published at lawprofessors.typepad.com

Citation

Workplace Prof, Is Automatic Enrollment Making a 401(k) Difference?, Labor Law Prof Blog (May 21, 2007) [The Library at LexBlog, LEX-WK-FQ2NBY1R, lexpid.org/FQ2NBY1R]

View the record

Filed under