Topic
Dormant Commerce Clause
110 published works
Budding Trends
The Not So Dormant Commerce Clause
By Slates C. Veazey, Noah Matthews
Few areas of law have been able to expose the contradictions of federal cannabis policy quite like the Dormant Commerce Clause. The Constitution’s long-standing rule against state economic protectionism has…
Libation Law Blog
Second Circuit Brings State-Tied Restorative Justice Licensing Under Constitutional Scrutiny
New York’s attempt to bake “home field advantage” into its cannabis licensing process just ran into a constitutional buzzsaw. In Variscite NY Four, LLC v. New York State Cannabis Control…
Cannabis Law Blog
Second Circuit Says Social Equity Goals Cannot Justify Discriminatory Application Process
Takeaways The Second Circuit invalidated New York’s cannabis licensing rules for discriminating against out-of-state applicants. The Court ruled that social equity goals cannot justify residency-based advantages. This Decision adds to…
Canna Law Blog
Federal Appeals Court Rejects Preferences for In-State Cannabis Applicants
By Tim Alger
A federal appellate court has ruled that a New York cannabis licensing rule favoring in-state residents is unconstitutional, because it discriminates against applicants residing out-of-state. We have been tracking this…
Libation Law Blog
Seventh Circuit Uncorks Dual Rationales in Chicago Wine v. Braun, Affirms State’s Direct Shipping Ban
A Decision Long in the Cellar On August 5, 2025—nearly four years after oral argument—the Seventh Circuit uncorked its opinion in Chicago Wine Co. v. Braun, a Dormant Commerce Clause…
Libation Law Blog
Standing Still: California Wine Law Challenge Falls on Procedural Grounds, Not the Dormant Commerce Clause
The federal court decision in Dwinell, LLC v. McCullough, No. 2:23-cv-10029-SB-KES (C.D. Cal. Apr. 7, 2025), offers an instructive reminder that the biggest hurdles for those challenging alcohol laws under…
Libation Law Blog
The 9th Circuit’s Decision in Day v. Henry: Another Step in the Developing Dormant Commerce Clause and 21st Amendment Jurisprudence
If you’ve been following along with dormant Commerce Clause litigation in the alcohol space, the 9th Circuit’s recent ruling in Day v. Henry should grab your attention. If you haven’t…
Washington Energy Report
Federal Appeals Court Appears Skeptical of State’s Ability to Question Federal Transmission Planning Decisions
By Dixon Wallace, S. Jennifer Panahi
On December 5, 2024, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit heard oral arguments in Transource Pennsylvania LLC v. Steven M. Defrank, et.al. The case presents the question…
Libation Law Blog
Breaking Down the Dormant Commerce Clause Case Against Unevenly Applied Rights Between In-State and Out-of-State Manufacturers: Buckel Family Wine v. Mosiman
In a decision from the United States District Court for the Southern District of Iowa pointing out once again that the issue is not with the three-tiered system, but with…
Agricultural Law and Taxation Blog
Top Ten Developments in Agricultural Law and Taxation in 2023 – (Part Six): Foreign Ownership of Agricultural Land
OverviewToday’s article is the sixth in a series concerning the Top Ten ag law and tax developments of 2023. To recap, here’s the list of the top developments so far:10…