Topic
Dormant Commerce Clause
110 published works
Libation Law Blog
Case involving alcohol law allowing in-state distilleries shipping direct to citizens and prohibiting out-of-state distilleries from doing the same allowed to proceed after direct comparison to Granholm.
In a classic Granholm v. Heald situation involving a lack of parity between in-state and out-of-state distilleries, Washington state allows in-state distilleries the privileges of direct sale and shipment of…
Libation Law Blog
Court finds statute barring retailer warehouse storage out of jurisdiction of alcoholic beverage control authority does not violate Dormant Commerce Clause. Finally, a Tennessee Wine case that is NOT about direct wine shipping.
We will look back to find that the greatest result of Tennessee Wine’s “test” allowing “each State leeway to enact the measures that its citizens believe are appropriate to address…
Libation Law Blog
1st Circuit closes ranks with those Circuits reading Tennessee Wine as requiring States prove alcohol laws discriminating against out-of-state interests affect health or safety goals or other legitimate interests
The Circuits are by and large falling into line regarding the implications and procedures of Tennessee Wine when Dormant Commerce Clause challenges are brought against State alcohol-related laws and regulations.…
Accessibility Defense
California versus the Constitution – who can regulate internet accessibility?
By Richard Hunt
Several other sources have reported on recent legislation in California that would establish WCAG 2.1 AA as the minimum accessibility requirement for websites that do business in California.¹ The bill…
Appellate Advocacy Blog
Court opinions are more than soundbites
Like many of you, I read the Supreme Court’s recent decision in National Pork Producers Council v. Ross, 143 S. Ct. 1142 (2023) very carefully. Not just because the dormant…
Drug & Device Law
NPP, DCC, And FDA-Regulated Medical Products
Politics makes strange bedfellows. So does the law. Weird cases also make weird law. The Supreme Court decision in National Pork Producers Council v. Ross, No. 21–468, — S. Ct.…
Libation Law Blog
6th Circuit hears oral argument in Ohio wine shipping case. Questions regarding implementing an out-of-state license and the evidentiary basis for factual assertions regarding public health and safety justifications for shipping prohibitions predominate.
The appeal results from a challenge in Ohio. An out-of-state wine retailer and an in-state wine enthusiast brought suit against the state of Ohio looking for a judgment that the…
Agricultural Law and Taxation Blog
SCOTUS Dismisses Pork Case – Case Not Properly Plead
OverviewIn a huge blow to pork producers (and consumers of pork products) nationwide, the Supreme Court of the United States (Court) has affirmed the U.S. Court of Appeals for the…
All About Advertising Law
Could Texas Ban the Sale of Union-Made Goods? After <em>National Pork Producers</em>, We Still Don’t Know
By Jay Johnson, Leonard L. Gordon
The Supreme Court's opinion last week in National Pork Producers Council v. Ross raises more questions than it answers regarding what state laws might violate the dormant Commerce Clause. California…
Commercial Litigation Update
A Calm and Prolific Day at the Court, and a Better Day for Criminal Defendants Than for the Second Circuit – SCOTUS Today
By Stuart M. Gerson, Epstein Becker Green
With the Justices largely in agreement across the board, the Court today issued five opinions. One of them provides a usefully definitive view of the limited nature of the so-called…